| Year | Player | Team |
|---|---|---|
| 1973 | Belmont Anderson | Second |
| 1974 | Belmont Anderson | Second |
| 1980 | Danny Ainge* | First |
| 1981 | Danny Ainge | First |
| 1983 | Devin Durrant | Second |
| 1984 | Devin Durrant | First |
| 1987 | Michael Smith | First |
| 1988 | Michael Smith** | First |
| 1989 | Michael Smith | First |
| 1990 | Andy Toolson | First |
| 1994 | Randy Reid | Third |
| 1996 | Randy Reid | Second |
| 1995 | Russell Larson | Second |
| 2017 | Eric Mika | Second |
| 2020 | TJ Haws | Third |
|
*Inducted into the CoSIDA Academic All-America Hall of Fame in 2000 **Academic All-American of the Year in Men's Basketball and All Sports |
||
| Year | Name |
|---|---|
| 1966 | Dick Nemelka |
| 1983 | Greg Kite |
| 1984 | Devin Durrant |
| 1987 | Brent Stephenson |
| 1989 | Michael Smith |
| 1990 | Andrew Toolson |
| 1991 | Steve Schreiner |
| 1992 | Mark Heslop |
| 1996 | Randy Reid |