BYU has had 16 conference players of the year in its history. The Cougars have also received eight pitchers of the year, four defensive players of the year, nine freshmen of the year and 10 coach of the year awards.
| Conference Players of the Year | Conference | Position | Year |
|---|---|---|---|
| Huntyr Ava | WCC | 1B | 2023 |
| Violet Zavodnik | WCC | OF | 2021 |
| Lexi Tarrow | WCC | OF | 2019 |
| Rylee Jensen-McFarland | WCC | OF | 2018 |
| Caitlyn Larsen Alldredge | WCC | 3B | 2017 |
| Ashley Thompson | WCC | 1B | 2016 |
| Gordy Bravo | WCC | OF | 2015 |
| JC Clayton | PCSC | SS | 2013 |
| Delaney Willard | WAC | OF | 2012 |
| Angeline Quiocho | MWC | 3B | 2010 |
| Jessica Purcell-Fitu | MWC | C | 2009 |
| Jodi Norton | MWC | SS | 2007 |
| Ianeta Le'i | MWC | 1B | 2006 |
| Lauren Watson-Perry | MWC | C | 2005 |
| Ianeta Le'i | MWC | 1B | 2004 |
| Oli Keohohou | MWC | OF | 2003 |
| Conference Pitchers of the Year | Conference | Year |
|---|---|---|
| Autumn Moffat-Korth | WCC | 2021 |
| Arissa Paulson | WCC | 2019 |
| Kerisa Viramontes (Co-Pitcher) | WCC | 2018 |
| McKenna Bull | WCC | 2017 |
| McKenna Bull | WCC | 2016 |
| McKenna Bull | WCC | 2015 |
| Paige Affleck | MWC | 2011 |
| Christie Zinanti | MWC | 2009 |
| Conference Defensive Player of the Year | Conference | Position | Year |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ailana Agbayani | WCC | SS | 2023 |
| Erin Miklus | WCC | 2B | 2019 |
| Lauren Bell | WCC | 2B | 2017 |
| Lauren Bell | WCC | SS | 2016 |
| Conference Freshman of the Year | Conference | Position | Year |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hailey Morrow | WCC | C | 2023 |
| Violet Zavodnik | WCC | OF | 2021 |
| Bridget Fleener | WCC | UTL | 2018 |
| Rylee Jensen-McFarland (Co-Freshman) | WCC | OF | 2017 |
| Sydney Broderick | WCC | C | 2014 |
| Gordy Bravo | PCSC | OF | 2013 |
| JC Clayton | MWC | SS | 2010 |
| Kristin Delahoussaye | MWC | 2B | 2008 |
| Oli Keohohou | MWC | OF | 2001 |
| Conference Coach of the Year | Conference | Year |
|---|---|---|
| Gordon Eakin | WCC | 2021 |
| Gordon Eakin | WCC | 2017 |
| Gordon Eakin (Co-Coach) | WCC | 2016 |
| Gordon Eakin | WCC | 2015 |
| Gordon Eakin | WCC | 2014 |
| Gordon Eakin | PCSC | 2013 |
| Gordon Eakin | MWC | 2011 |
| Gordon Eakin | MWC | 2010 |
| Gordon Eakin | MWC | 2009 |
| Mary Kay Amicone | MWC | 2001 |
Note: Following the 23-game 2020 season, no conference awards were given due to the coronavirus outbreak. The season was suspended on March 12, 2020, and no conference games had been played.